BAXTER'S BREAKDOWNS
March 9, 2016 posted by

Walter Lantz’ “Fish Fry” (1944)

FF6-cat-eyes

Here’s an Oscar-nominated Walter Lantz cartoon with Andy Panda!

As soon as his enduring Oswald the Lucky Rabbit series began to fade in the mid-‘30s, Walter Lantz encouraged his studio to create new star characters. Despite the studio’s desperation to create a lasting series, their new creations were quite meager, and unable to sustain such aspirations. Among these characters were three simian brothers (Meany, Miny and Moe), and human characters, including a series which spoofed Gay Nineties melodrama featuring Nell the fair damsel and the grotesquely racist Lil’ Eightball. Different animal characters also emerged, such as Baby-Face Mouse and Charlie Cuckoo. Even outside contributions couldn’t guarantee success; famed Hungarian illustrator Willy Pogany and his wife Elaine’s Peterkin character — appearing only in 1939’s Scrambled Eggs — garnered little interest from audiences.

andy-panda-headLantz heard the news of Su-Lin, a large panda cub donated to the Chicago Zoo, and flew there to observe the newborn, and draw inspirational sketches. One of Universal’s newsreel cameramen captured footage of Su-Lin, and Lantz used it as reference for his probable character, which he ultimately named and debuted in Life Begins for Andy Panda (1939). The little panda’s first few cartoons paired him with his father Poppa Panda (Crazy House, Knock Knock, Mouse Trappers, Dizzy Kitty), but Andy soon matured– quite literally, too– into his own solo cartoons by 1942.

Director Shamus Culhane particularly detested the good-natured panda, claiming his cartoons to be “too goddamn sweet and cuddly.” In Culhane’s defense, Andy is too passive a character, compared to Lantz’s provocative woodpecker. In some of Andy’s cartoons, only the nature of given situations and the quirks of supporting characters redeem them— not the character itself. In Fish Fry, especially, Andy is used as a framing device, as he walks along with his new goldfish. Later, a famished cat (wonderfully voiced by Lionel Stander) robs him of his pet and kicks Andy into a cement mixer, left aside for a good portion of the cartoon. Culhane directed three other cartoons with Andy (Meatless Tuesday, The Painter and the Pointer and Mousie Come Home); like Fish Fry, he often chose not to give the character much screen-time.

andy-panda-title225Culhane recalled in his book, Talking Animals and Other People, his dissatisfaction from the storyboard’s lack of verve. While the cat puts his hand around the fish bowl, Andy’s goldfish bites his finger—the payoff originally stopped there. Culhane extended the sequence by having the goldfish comfort the cat and produce a first-aid kit; instead of bandaging him, the fish takes out a set of false teeth and bites the cat’s finger again, soaring him into the air. Culhane’s contributions were stronger, lending a more vicious side to a vulnerable creature, similar to Bob Clampett’s depiction of Tweety.

Emery Hawkins handles a wonderful sequence where the cat disguises himself as a dehydrated explorer. Scene 21 has some great acting and expressions, as the cat contently chews water from the fishbowl, thinking he has lapped up Andy’s goldfish. Moments later, he notices something amiss as he pokes his tongue around both cheeks. The cat spins and angrily glares at the goldfish, still in his fish bowl. As an animator, Hawkins was something of a perfectionist. “He had his own standards of quality and would often throw out a whole day’s work, just after I had assured him that it was a beautiful piece of animation,” Culhane said. “Emery was never satisfied with any of his work and suffered more agonies of anxiety and frustration than any other animation I have ever met.”

The draft for Fish Fry, even more so than those for Culhane’s cartoons, is a bit unreliable in its scene assignments. Scene 7, with Andy whistling to “Polly Wolly Doodle” after he acquires his new pet is assigned to Pat Matthews, but the drawing/animation is more sculpted than his usual work; it actually belongs to Verne Harding. The second half of the cat’s “merger” (scenes 37 and 38) between him and Andy is assigned to Emery Hawkins, but it looks comparably weak in the cartoon; Les Kline handles the scenes instead. Oddly enough, Kline draws the cat in different ways in his scenes; in scene 49, when his head is caught in the sewer, he is seen with rather large pupils, which aren’t seen in Kline’s other shots.

FishFry-Drawing600In scene 61, Matthews is assigned a shot of Andy running and catching the airborne fish; again, those are Harding’s scenes. The quick cuts in scenes 63-65 are credited to three different animators; judging from the dry-brush smears, these seem to be Don Williams’ animation in those cuts (instead of only sc. 63.) It’s unclear how Pat Matthews, or other artist’s scenes, were assigned to others. It takes a keen eye, developed from watching other scenes of their work, to notice this misinformation.

Dick Lundy is assigned to only one shot in Fish Fry; Variety reported the cartoon’s production began on December 8, 1943. Lundy had started directing by late March 1944, therefore it could be one of, if not the last, scenes he animated for Lantz before being promoted. Interestingly, Milt Schaffer, Ben Hardaway’s writing partner at the studio, is given two shots in the cartoon of the goldfish in the sewer, drawing him with droopy jowls. Schaffer previously animated for Disney in the ‘30s; however, it’s worth inquiring if he only animated on this cartoon while Lundy moved to the directing chair. (It’s still ambiguous if Schaffer animated on other Lantz cartoons besides this one.)

As a story-man and director, Hardaway often ended his Warners cartoons with antagonists losing their sanity, as they head off into the horizon, for instance, in Daffy Duck & Egghead and Hare-Um Scare-Um. The ending for this cartoon is bewildering; after the cat bumps into various objects, there seems to be an abrupt cut as he runs off into the horizon and runs back to the bulldog. Verne Harding does a wonderful job on the animation and Lionel Stander gives a truly manic vocal reading (“I made it! I made it! I made it!!”), but because of the abrupt cut, the reason for the cat’s sudden outburst is lost upon the viewer.

Fish Fry was released on June 19, 1944, about six months after it started production; there doesn’t seem to be a delay as there were for cartoons from Warner Bros, but the year’s output from Lantz was significantly half the number of Warners cartoons for ’44 (and were entirely directed by Culhane.) The cartoon was nominated for an Academy Award, but lost to the brilliant Tom and Jerry cartoon, Mouse Trouble.

There won’t be a breakdown for next week. I’ve just started working on a highly anticipated video release, so I think a week off might suffice. As for the Easter holiday coming in a couple weeks, readers should know what breakdown’s arriving next.

Enjoy the breakdown video, folks! I’m going to go rest easy now…

Fish-Fry-Draft

(Thanks to Mark Kausler, Yowp, Frank Young and Larry Tremblay for their help.)

20 Comments

  • The ending is simply explained – the cat runs off into the distance, then dashes back to shout “I made it!”, because he managed to exit without hitting something else.

  • I had always assumed that Life Begins for Andy Panda drew its title from the Mickey Rooney film Life Begins for Andy Hardy, but it can’t be, as the cartoon was released two years earlier. Were both drawing on some other source?

    • According to Jim Korkis’ Animation Anecdotes book, the possible given name is from the 1932 book Life Begins at 40.

    • That’s a good point, Stephen; I always assumed that myself, not realizing the chronology. Truly, with just swapping “Panda” for “Hardy,” that was such the logical explanation, and was the sort of thing Lantz always liked to do (King Klunk, among others)

      So, was their dual inspiration the movie “Life Begins” (1932) with Loretta Young? Daryl Zanuck considered that a headline movie, so I assume it was widely seen, though it’s faded in memory now. I wonder if there wasn’t a meme that already existed then with Life Begins for…

      The Andy Hardy movies as a series did pre-date Andy Panda, with titles like “Love Finds Andy Hardy” (1938) so it’s my guess that Andy Hardy was in mind, in some manner, when the first Andy Panda cartoon got that title.

  • “As for the Easter holiday coming in a couple weeks, readers should know what breakdown’s arriving next.”

    Easter Yeggs?

    As for this cartoon, my favorite animation was by (no surprise) Emery Hawkins and Dick Lundy, whose work on this one was sadly all too brief.

    • I’m guessing “Egg-Cracker Suite.”

      Anyone else?

    • How sbout Walt Disney’s Funny Little Bunnies?

  • “Start your day with Emery Hawkins footage” I always say.

    Sure, Andy himself was a bland character, but the cartoons he’s in are generally good-to-great, as evidenced here. Obviously, the creative challenges of making a lot out of a little were routinely met at the Lantz studio. In 1940s Golden Age fashion.

    BTW, I always ‘got’ the ending of FF, even as a kid. But I can see how it might have moved a bit abruptly to be missed by others.

  • Nice group effort here by the animators, and I agree that Hawkins’ animation stands out. And wow, Lundy really goes off model with the cat here in his brief sequence. Interesting point you bring up about Schaffer animating on this one, Devon. Yes, that was an unusual instance.

  • “Director Shamus Culhane particularly detested the good-natured panda, claiming his cartoons to be “too goddamn sweet and cuddly.””

    Is that why he made him meaner and tougher-looking in “The Painter and the Pointer”? Did he hope that the new version would catch on?

    “The draft for Fish Fry, even more so than those for Culhane’s cartoons, is a bit unreliable in its scene assignments. ”

    Some of the other Lantz drafts have animators’ names crossed out and replaced by other names. But without those amendments, I don’t know if it’s a good idea to put names on the video which are based on your educated guesswork as if they were confirmed fact. Maybe put a question mark after the name?

  • What I’m wondering who did Andy Panda’s voice during his run for Walter Lantz, I know most were female with the exception of Daws Butler doing Andy’s voice for Spook-A-Nanny (1964). But there several Andy Panda Cartoons where Andy didn’t spoke a word such as in Poet & Peasant, Polonaise (with Woody Woodpecker) and my personal favorite The Bandmaster (The overture to Zampa).

    • Walter Tetley, later known as the voice of Sherman in “Mr. Peabody and Sherman”, was the voice of Andy Panda from “Painter and the Pointer” until “Scrappy Birthday”, Andy’s final short. Tetley was a good choice for Andy’s voice because, like Tetley in real life, Andy was an adult male with a high-pitched voice.

  • Hi Devon,
    All I get when I click the video is a sign that says “the video doesn’t exist”! Can you re-post it?
    Mark Kausler

    • That’s odd. It’s playing just fine on my computer.
      Is anyone else having that same issue?

    • Hey Mark, refresh your browser. The video works fine on my computer – and no one else has written in to complain.

  • Does anyone know why Andy, in his cartoons of this period, does that peculiar lame wolf-whistle during the credits of his cartoons? That apparent non-sequitur has puzzled me for decades!

    • I always thought Andy was doing a variant of Lou Costello’s “whistling tic” – which Mel Blanc used in his imitation as “Catstello” – and especially since A&C were Universal’s #1 comedy stars at the time.

  • Good point, Jerry Beck, about the ANDY PANDA wolf whistle. I never connected it with Lou Costello, but that makes sense, even though the whistle isn’t exactly the same. As for Andy Panda being “too damned cute and cuddly”, well, to me, it never hurt those early cartoons since he was supposed to be a baby in the first two or three, and Sarah Berner’s chosen voice characterization didn’t really hurt, either. I thought Andy in cartoons like “THE PAINTER AND THE POINTER” could be a bit cruel, but otherwise, Culhane’s cartoons were entertaining.

  • “Dick Lundy is assigned to only one shot in Fish Fry; Variety reported the cartoon’s production began on December 8, 1943. Lundy had started directing by late March 1944, therefore it could be one of, if not the last, scenes he animated for Lantz before being promoted.”

    Given that his name is absent from both the on-screen credits and the drafts from the year’s earlier releases, it looks more like this was the *first* scene he animated for Lantz. (Unless they were released out of production order)

    • I hadn’t thought of that. I forgot the Lantz production numbers were readily available on the Lantz-O-Pedia.
      Thanks for lookin’ out!

Leave a Reply to Peter Mork Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *