Animation History
June 15, 2026 posted by E.O. Costello

Blu-Ray Review: “Fleischer Cartoons Greatest Hits, Volume 1”

In the wake of my review of Cartoon Logic’s Famous Studios Champion Collection (which can be found here), I am following up with a review of another recent BluRay utilizing Cartoon Logic’s restoration expertise: namely, Fleischer Cartoons Greatest Hits, Volume 1 (a co-production with Jane Fleischer’s Fabulous Fleischer Cartoons Restored).

I’m happy to say I think this is another case where cartoon fans will find it worthwhile to get this release, since it contains attractively presented material, supported by informed commentary.

The collection contains a variety of cartoons originally released between 1923 and 1941. The set includes a number of silent-era Koko the Clown cartoons, some Talkartoons from the early sound era, a handful of Betty Boop cartoons, one Screen Song, one of the color, two-reeler Popeye cartoons, a few Color Classics, and in one outlier, one of the Superman cartoons the Fleischer studio produced shortly before it was taken over by Paramount.

As you can imagine, a collection calling itself “Greatest Hits” is going to have a number of cartoons that have been presented in many collections before, and broadcast many times. At least one of these cartoons I quite vividly recall from Leonard Maltin’s long-ago presentation Cartoon Madness, which was one of my first introductions to Fleischer cartoons. However, there are a few cartoons in the collection that I believe have not been in general circulation before, principally a few of the silent cartoons. This fact alone I think justifies collectors taking a serious look at the collection.

Here’s a breakdown of the cartoons on the set (these are not in the order they are presented in the collection):

Silent Cartoons: The Fortune Teller (1923), Cartoon Factory (1924), Ko-Ko at the Circus (1926), Ko-Ko’s Earth Control (1928), Ko-Ko’s Haunted House (1928)
Talkartoons: Hot Dog (1930), Swing You Sinners! (1930)
Betty Boop: Dizzy Dishes (1930), Barnacle Bill (1930), Mysterious Mose (1930), Betty Boop’s Crazy Inventions (1933), Betty in Blunderland (1934), Betty Boop and Grampy (1935), A Language All My Own (1935)
Color Classics: Christmas Comes But Once a Year (1936), Somewhere in Dreamland (1936), Small Fry (1939)
Popeye: Popeye the Sailor Meets Ali Baba’s Forty Thieves (1937)
Screen Songs: Dinah (1933)
Superman: The Mechanical Monsters (1941)

I would say that this is a pretty representative sample of Fleischer cartoons of the 1920s and 1930s, with The Mechanical Monsters and possibly Small Fry being outliers from much later in the run. I think I would have been tempted to leave out the Superman cartoon (perhaps for a “Florida” set that could also include the recently re-found “Stone Age” series pilot) and perhaps swap in Dancing on the Moon (1935) for Small Fry, if an appropriate copy could have been found, to perhaps tighten up the chronology. But that’s a minor point.

The silent cartoons come off very well in the set. Musicians Ben Model and Kevin MacLeod do a very good job, in my view, of providing atmospheric music that sounds like it belongs. It also helps that the cartoons are both funny and, in their restored states, show how sophisticated the Fleischer studios were in their 1920s animation, especially when it comes to effects-heavy stories such as Ko-Ko’s Earth Control (which has long been a personal favorite of mine). In this segment, perhaps the winner is Cartoon Factory, in which a number of mechanical Max Fleischers cause Ko-Ko no end of trouble. I saw this for the first time at Film Forum earlier this year, in a program presented by Jerry Beck, and the audience greatly enjoyed it. These cartoons are a significant reason to buy the set.

Max Fleischer about to torment Ko-Ko in “Cartoon Factory.”

The selection of Swing You Sinners! (a slight reworking of a hit song from a Paramount film of 1930, Honey) is inevitable in a “greatest hits” compilation of Fleischer cartoons, since it’s loaded with the surrealistic gags that many associate with the studio of the early 1930s, and in a cleaned-up state, is a treat to watch.

“Swing You Sinners!

I imagine that, among other cartoons, Snow White and Poor Cinderella are being kept for another set, but the choices for Betty Boop’s representation on this set are quite defensible. Dizzy Dishes, after all, is regarded as her debut, with Betty Boop’s Crazy Inventions and Betty in Blunderland showing her off in an appealing format. (It’s been observed by others that Crazy Inventions was likely a subject close to the hearts of the Fleischers.) One of the interesting choices is A Language All My Own, and here, the commentary by Rob Waldman, son of de facto director Myron Waldman, is quite helpful, in that we see what an unusual cartoon this was for the time, with respect to the research the elder Waldman did to get the Japanese elements of the cartoon right. The cartoon is respectful, cheery and bouncy, and is very much worth watching and thinking over. Betty in Blunderland does make you wonder why Paramount chose Harman-Ising for animated inserts in its 1933 adaptation of Alice in Wonderland instead of the Fleischers; the presentation here is loaded with charm, and takes in many of the characters from the stories you don’t often see referenced elsewhere.

Betty Boop and a vast supporting cast in “Betty in Blunderland.”

“Small Fry”

All three of the Color Classics come off well. In particular, I think Small Fry, however much it might be an outlier in time (being a Florida production), shines in the restoration. To my mind, the scene in which the titular little tough-guy fish meets up with scary creatures in a cave foreshadows some of the use of line and color that would be used in Mr. Bug Goes to Town (1941), when Hoppity gets electrocuted. The very familiar Christmas Comes But Once a Year looks very sharp, in contrast to many muddy public domain sources. However saccharine one might find Somewhere in Dreamland (you wonder just how much of this sort of thing even Depression-era audiences could take), the cartoon does look attractive in a fresh print, especially since heavy use is made of the famous three-dimensional backgrounds.

Ali Baba is quite familiar to Fleischer fans, and it’s handy to have it in readily accessible format. (If, in future sets, Aladdin is included, I wonder if the well-known Popular Science short subject that touched heavily on that cartoon will be included to complement it.) Given the ready availability of the Popeye cartoons on DVD, I think it was wise to limit Popeye to one of the high points of his 1930s appearances.

“Somewhere In Dreamland”

I was slightly surprised to see only one Screen Song presented, though it is a very good one, featuring the Mills Brothers in a polished performance. Whether this is due to music rights, I’m not certain. (“Dinah” was written in 1925, so it is public domain.) It would be nice to see more from this series in future sets, especially since the Fleischer studio was very well known for this series, going back to some of the earliest Lee DeForest experiments in sound. (There’s another Mills Brothers Screen Song, When Yuba Plays the Rhumba on the Tuba, I’d dearly love to see in an unchopped format, and Time on My Hands is truly a Screen Song that deserves to be presented well.)

Lastly, the Superman cartoon that is included is undeniably one of the key cartoons in the series, along with The Bulleteers and Billion Dollar Limited. In this particular case, I think it’s the commentary by Paul Dini (one of the key figures behind the Superman cartoons of the 1990s, and a devoted Superman fan) that makes its inclusion in this set worthwhile.

Speaking of commentaries, a team comprised of Charlie Judkins, producer Thad Komorowski, Ray Pointer, Bob Jaques, Leonard Maltin, Will Friedwald, Rob Waldman, Mark Kausler and Dini do give a significant amount of context and interesting information regarding the cartoons, and for cartoons on this set that are familiar, it’s still a good idea to listen to these experts and get some fresh insights.

In conclusion, I recommend this set, especially if you purchased the Champion Collection. If more sets can be produced, it would help flesh out the availability of the non-Popeye Fleischer output.

10 Comments

  • I must echo the opinion here on this set. I rather like it, and I’m glad to have all these cartoons as best as they could possibly look at sound. Every copy I’ve ever heard of “swing you sinners“ has been extremely muddy or dull. You can’t say that about this! My hopes for the next set, of course our far more precode Betty Boop cartoons. We all know what those are, and we all probably feel the same way. There are so many of those to choose from. Seeing those in high definition, the highest possible, will definitely be a revelation.

    As for the addition of the Popeye, cartoon, it is definitely among one of my favorites. I remember seeing this on television so many times when I was a kid. I marveled at the beauty of that animation! I think Popeye was at the height of his popularity at this time. Thanks for this review, and yes, thank you to all the people who did commentary because those help my particular enjoyment of these cartoons. For those who don’t know what I’m talking about, I am totally blind and I buy a lot of classic animation on DVD and Blu-ray because I also like the soundtracks to them. This is definitely no exception!

  • It’s great that these cartoons have been restored and are being made available on home video, and I hope that Volume 1 will be the first of many. I don’t want to quibble about the selections, other than to say that any initial collection purporting to be Fleischer’s “Greatest Hits” should have included one of the Cab Calloway cartoons.

    I’m excited to learn that the first Stone Age cartoon has been found! I can’t wait to hear the lyrics to “Primitive Rhythm”!

    So you think that “Somewhere in Dreamland” might have been too saccharine for audiences in 1936, when Shirley Temple was the number one box office draw? Somehow I doubt it.

  • How does the Superman short look and sound compared to the versions that have shown up from Warner Bros during the DVD and Blu-Ray reissue era? Is it sourced from negatives, or from prints? Are the opening and closing correct for The Mechanical Monsters?

    • We used a 35mm print for this version, and it does have the correct music.

      • Nice!

  • Thank you, Mr. Costello, for this review!

    I pre-ordered that puppy as soon as it was available for pre-order. I was especially happy to see the cartoon “Hot Dog” (1930), the first Talkartoon with Bimbo, in this release. This Blu-Ray DVD is a very nice eclectic mix of cartoons – from Ko-Ko to Superman and a lot of folks in between.

    Note that “Dizzy Dishes,” Barnacle Bill,” and “Mysterious Mose” are also Talkartoons.

    My one disappointment is that there is no “Accordion Joe” in there. But, of course, there is always hope…

    In case any of you care, here are the twenty cartoons in chronological order, which is the way, I prefer them. The Ko-Kos above are in order. Release dates are listed on the disk cover, which I think is pretty handy. The cartoons are on the disk in alphabetical order:

    1. The Fortune Teller (Out of the Inkwell; Ko-Ko the Clown) (10/1/1923)
    2. Cartoon Factory (Out of the Inkwell; Ko-Ko the Clown) (2/21/1924)
    3. Ko-Ko at the Circus (Out of the Inkwell; Ko-Ko the Clown) (5/1/1926)
    4. Ko-Ko’s Earth Control (Inkwell Imps; Ko-Ko the Clown) (3/31/1928)
    5. Ko-Ko’s Haunted House (Inkwell Imps; Ko-Ko the Clown) (4/28/1928)
    6. Hot Dog (Talkartoon; Bimbo’s first Talkartoon) (3/29/1930)
    7. Dizzy Dishes (Talkartoon; Bimbo; Betty Boop’s debut) (8/9/1930)
    8. Barnacle Bill [Talkartoon; “Nancy Lee” (Betty Boop), Bimbo] (8/30/1930)
    9. Swing You Sinners! (Talkartoon) (9/24/1930)
    10. Mysterious Mose (Talkartoon; Betty Boop, Bimbo) (12/27/1930)
    11. Dinah (Screen Song; with the Mills Brothers) (1/13/1933)
    12. Betty Boop’s Crazy Inventions (Betty Boop series) (1/27/1933)
    13. Betty in Blunderland (Betty Boop) (4/6/1934)
    14. A Language All My Own (Betty Boop) (7/19/1935)
    15. Betty Boop and Grampy (Betty Boop) (8/16/1935)
    16. Somewhere in Dreamland (Color Classic; the Fleischer Bros.’ first cartoon in full three-color Technicolor?) (1/17/1936)
    17. Christmas Comes But Once a Year (Color Classic) (12/4/1936)
    18. Popeye the Sailor Meets Ali Baba’s Forty Thieves (Popeye; color, two reels) (11/26/1937)
    19. Small Fry (Color Classic) (4/21/1939)
    20. The Mechanical Monsters (Superman) (11/28/1941)

    If you haven’t bought it yet, buy it! I’m very much looking forward to the next release.

    (What does this do to Steve Stanchfield’s other planned Betty Boop DVDs? We wonders, aye, we wonders…)

    • There’s only one Betty Boop thing in the pipeline, and it’s a “Semi-Special” set from mostly 16mm prints, so no conflict at all (and no repeating titles). I’ve helped with the Fleischer project restorations myself, and Tommy Stathes’ excellent “Back to the Inkwell” set. It’s an excellent time for Fleischer animation- it’s so nice to have these cartoons looking so beautiful.

  • I got the blu-ray a few weeks ago, it was a great set overall! My only complaint is that I don’t like the prints they used for Popeye Meets Ali-baba and The Mechanical Monsters. The colors looked off to me compared to previous restorations. Well, at least they restored the original soundtracks to them.

  • I appreciate posts like this because physical media details still matter for collectors and resellers. Things like edition quality, bonus features, subtitles, packaging, and availability can make a big difference when deciding whether a DVD or Blu-ray is worth keeping in a collection.

  • “The very familiar Christmas Comes but Once a Year looks very sharp…” when I saw the aforementioned on YouTube a few years ago…I was blown away by the restoration of it from the opening Paramount mountain to the rotating tree at the end. I wanted…no DEMANDED that this be put on DVD. Apparently, I was not alone. Seeing it on Blu-ray even on a pedestrian 19-inch flat screen still impresses me.

    Rodolfo’s critique on “Popeye Meets Ali Baba” and “The Mechanical Monsters” I guess there has to be a trade-off somewhere.

    Liked the restored opening credits effort on “Betty Boop and Grampy.” Seeing Grampy cut a rug to “Tiger Rag” is a way to perhaps start a weekend or get that party going.

    “In conclusion, I recommend this set, especially if you purchased the Champion Collection.”

    Just so happens…I did. No regrets.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *